Settling vs. Going to Trial: Pros and Cons in Whiplash Cases

Whiplash is one of the most common injuries that occur during car accidents. When someone is involved in a car crash, the sudden jolt or impact can cause the neck to snap back and forth, leading to damage to the soft tissues in the neck. Whiplash can lead to pain, stiffness, and in some cases, long-term complications. For those who suffer from whiplash after an accident, deciding whether to settle the case out of court or go to trial is a significant decision. Understanding the differences between settling and going to trial can help make this choice easier. Both options have their pros and cons, and each can impact the outcome of your case in different ways. Christian & Christian Law can assist you in navigating the complexities of your whiplash car accident case by providing dedicated support and tailored legal strategies to secure the compensation you deserve.

What is a Whiplash Case?

Whiplash occurs when the head and neck are suddenly forced in one direction and then jerked back. This kind of injury is often seen in car accidents, especially rear-end collisions. In a whiplash case, the injured person might file a claim to recover money for medical bills, lost wages, and pain they suffered because of the injury. However, these cases can be complicated because whiplash is not always easy to diagnose. Some people recover quickly from a whiplash injury, while others may experience long-term pain and discomfort. Insurance companies may try to downplay the injury or argue that it is not as severe as claimed. This is why some people end up in legal battles to get the compensation they deserve.

Settling a Whiplash Case – Pros

One of the main reasons people choose to settle a whiplash case is to avoid the stress and length of a trial. Settling can often provide a quicker resolution, allowing the injured person to receive compensation sooner rather than later. The settlement process typically involves negotiations between the injured person’s attorney and the insurance company or the person responsible for the accident. If both sides can agree on a fair amount, the case is resolved without the need for a trial.

Another advantage of settling is that it can be less risky than going to trial. At trial, there is no guarantee that the judge or jury will rule in your favor. You might end up with less compensation than what was offered in settlement negotiations. By settling, you have more control over the outcome and can ensure that you receive something rather than risking everything at trial.

South Carolina Injury Attorneys

Only Serving People, Never Companies

Founded in 1975, Christian & Christian has deep roots in the community.

Learn more about our attorneys

Only Serving People, Never Companies

Founded in 1975, Christian & Christian has deep roots in the community.

Learn more about our attorneys

Settling can also be a more private matter. Trials are public, which means that details about your injury, your medical history, and your personal life might become part of the public record. If you settle, the case is typically kept confidential, which allows you to maintain more privacy.

Settling a Whiplash Case – Cons

While settling has its advantages, it also has its downsides. One of the biggest drawbacks is that you might end up with less money than you would if you went to trial and won. In many cases, the initial settlement offer is lower than what you might deserve. Insurance companies often try to settle cases quickly and for as little as possible. If you accept the first offer, you may not get enough to cover all your medical expenses, lost wages, and future needs.

Another disadvantage is that settling means you give up your right to pursue further compensation in the future. Once you agree to settle, you cannot change your mind if your condition worsens or you discover additional medical problems related to the injury. This finality can be a downside, especially if you are still unsure about the long-term impact of your whiplash injury.

Some people also feel that settling allows the other party to avoid accountability. By settling out of court, the person or company responsible for your injury does not have to admit fault or answer for their actions in front of a judge. This can leave some people feeling unsatisfied with the outcome.

Everyone there was very professional, knowledgeable, and friendly. My car was totaled, and I was a little intimidated talking with a couple of other lawyers in Greenville. But with Christian and Christian, not only did they answer my questions, but they did so in a way that made what could have been a hectic situation, easy. Overall, an excellent experience with high quality lawyers who truly go above and beyond and really try to get you the results or answers you need.

—Rob Young

I met Josh like 4 years ago when my Son was injured at Daycare. He was very concerned about the well being of my Child and Me. Very Understanding Professional and Just a great Staff. If You need a Lawyer that’s all about YOU this is the Place. I just closed a Case on 6/23/2021 from a injury on a Property. They handled everything because no one else would help Me. I’m forever grateful for Your hard Work and Time. Once again Thank You Josh and Sally.

—Rezillai Henderson

My husband was referred to this law firm from another lawyer after his mother passed away while residing in a nursing home. Matt took on his case and we are pleased with how everything turned out. It took a long, long time to finally settle, but it was worth the wait. The staff here is friendly and I’d be happy to recommend them to anyone needing legal assistance.

— Jen

I was referred to Harold by a family friend, and I couldn’t be happier. He took the time to listen to my case, answered all my questions and truly treated me like a friend not a client. His knowledge of medical malpractice is priceless he actually successfully won, one of the first medical malpractice cases in Greenville County.

— Lindsey

Going to Trial – Pros

Taking your whiplash case to trial can be a good option if you feel the settlement offer is too low or if you want to hold the other party accountable for their actions. One of the main benefits of going to trial is that you might receive a higher compensation amount. A jury or judge could award you more than what was offered during settlement negotiations, especially if they believe that the injury had a serious impact on your life.

Another benefit is that going to trial can provide a sense of justice. At trial, the details of the accident are thoroughly examined, and the other party may have to answer for their role in causing your injury. For some people, this sense of justice is important. They want the person responsible for their injury to be held accountable in a court of law.

Going to trial also allows for the possibility of a jury deciding your case. While this can be risky, as juries can be unpredictable, it can also work in your favor. If the jury is sympathetic to your situation, they may award a significant amount of compensation.

Going to Trial – Cons

Despite the potential benefits, going to trial has several downsides. One of the biggest disadvantages is that trials take time. It can take months or even years for a case to reach trial, and during that time, you might not receive any compensation for your injury. This can be especially difficult if you are facing medical bills or lost wages due to the injury.

Trials are also unpredictable. While you may think you have a strong case, there is no guarantee that the jury or judge will rule in your favor. You might end up with less compensation than what was offered during settlement negotiations, or you could lose the case entirely. This uncertainty makes going to trial a risky option.

Another downside is that trials can be stressful. The process of preparing for trial, giving testimony, and facing cross-examination can be emotionally draining. You may also have to relive the details of the accident and your injury, which can be difficult for some people. Additionally, trials are public, which means that personal details about your injury and your life may become part of the public record.

Related Videos

Value of a Personal Injury Case

Choosing a Personal Injury Attorney

Making the Decision

Deciding whether to settle your whiplash case or take it to trial is not an easy choice. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice will depend on your personal situation. If you want a quicker resolution and are satisfied with the settlement offer, settling might be the right choice for you. However, if you believe you deserve more compensation or want to hold the other party accountable, going to trial might be worth the risk.

It is important to speak with an attorney who can help you weigh the pros and cons of each option and determine the best course of action for your case. An attorney can help you negotiate a fair settlement or represent you in court if you decide to go to trial. No matter which option you choose, having legal representation can increase your chances of receiving the compensation you deserve for your whiplash injury.

If you or a loved one has suffered from a whiplash injury, the decision to settle or go to trial can feel overwhelming. Having experienced legal support on your side can make all the difference. The attorneys at Christian & Christian Law are here to help you understand your options and guide you through the legal process. Whether you decide to settle or take your case to court, we are committed to fighting for the compensation you deserve. Contact Christian & Christian Law today for a consultation, and let us help you navigate your whiplash case with confidence.